Top 50 US Wines of 2026: Wines Ranked 10–1

By | 21 November 2026

Decanter’s top 10 selections for its 2026 list highlight wines that stand out not only for their quality, but also for the stories behind them. The selection spans California and Oregon, from classic Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Noir to sparkling wine and less common regional styles.

No. 10: Domaine de la Côte, La Côte Pinot Noir 2024

From a steep, sheltered slope in the Sta Rita Hills, this Pinot Noir earned the highest score among Domaine de la Côte’s 2024 wines. Two cold springs sharply reduced yields, leaving grapes with intense flavors and firm tannins. Winemaker Sashi Moorman handled the fruit gently to preserve balance and elegance.

The wine was released exclusively in magnum, with just 1,536 bottles produced. The larger format is intended to support slow aging, and the wine is expected to develop over many years.

Read the full review

No. 9: HdV, Comandante Chardonnay 2023

Comandante is a small barrel selection from Hyde Vineyard, one of California’s best-known Chardonnay sites. The 2023 release combines eight barrels, including fruit from the vineyard’s Old Wente clone plantings.

HdV winemaker Guillaume Boudet takes a restrained approach, aging the wine in French oak for about 18 months, with roughly one-third new barrels. The wine honors a Spanish ancestor of the Hyde family who served as a Comandante in early 19th-century Santa Barbara—and who reportedly knew how to host a party.

Read the full review

No. 8: Antiquum Farm, Little Bud Pinot Noir 2024

At Antiquum Farm in the southern Willamette Valley, founder Stephen Hagen practices what he calls “grazing-based viticulture.” Pigs, sheep, chickens, geese and ducks help manage weeds and fertilize the land, while the farm’s approach focuses on building a healthy community of soil organisms.

Little Bud—named for Hagen’s son—blends fruit from 11 sections of the estate’s Pinot Noir plantings. The vines grow on a south-facing ridge in volcanic and sedimentary bellpine soils, producing grapes with thick skins, high acidity and concentrated fruit.

Read the full review

No. 7: Domaine Carneros, Ultra Brut 2020

Founded by Champagne’s Taittinger family in 1987, Domaine Carneros has long produced traditional-method sparkling wines from estate-grown grapes. Its Ultra Brut is a vintage-dated, bone-dry style that benefits from ripe fruit and crisp acidity.

The 2020 is the first vintage in which Zak Miller led the sparkling-wine program, after working for a decade alongside founding winemaker Eileen Crane. The wines spend at least three years aging on their lees. The vintage also coincided with Remi Cohen’s arrival as CEO.

Read the full review

No. 6: Caraccioli Cellars, Syrah 2022

Caraccioli Cellars’ Syrah comes from rocky blocks in the Escolle Vineyard in the Santa Lucia Highlands. The Caraccioli family first planted the estate mainly with Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, then grafted some vines to Syrah in 2018. The promising results led them to expand the variety to six acres.

The family’s winemaking roots are in sparkling wine, but its current team has broadened the estate’s focus. This Syrah suggests the variety could have a bright future in the region.

Read the full review

No. 5: Keplinger Wines, Sumo 2023

Winemaker Helen Keplinger’s Sumo is the list’s only wine based on Petite Sirah. The grapes come from Shake Ridge Vineyard in Amador County, at 1,750 feet in the Sierra Foothills.

Rather than use Petite Sirah as a blending grape, Keplinger makes it the central variety, co-fermenting it with a small amount of Viognier. She also blends in Syrah co-fermented with Viognier. The result is a full-bodied, mineral-driven wine that combines dark fruit with freshness and complexity.

Read the full review

No. 4: Hirsch Vineyards, Maritime Pinot Noir 2023

Hirsch Vineyards began as a sheep ranch and later became a sought-after source of Pinot Noir grapes for producers including Littorai, Kistler, Williams Selyem and Failla. Founder David Hirsch planted vines in 1980 and gradually expanded the vineyard, working with longtime vineyard manager Everardo Robledo.

His daughter, Jasmine Hirsch, became winemaker in 2019. The Maritime bottling comes from one of the estate’s most exposed areas, where a gap in the ridgeline lets coastal fog and wind reach the vines. It took decades of planting and replanting before the site produced this distinctive, savory Pinot Noir.

Read the full review

No. 3: Louis M. Martini, The Gryphon Cabernet Sauvignon 2023

The Gryphon offers a Napa Cabernet from a historic producer at a comparatively accessible price. Louis M. Martini was the first bonded winery built in Napa Valley after Prohibition, and founder Louis Martini bought the Monte Rosso Vineyard in 1936.

For the 2023 blend, winemaker Zach Watkins combined fruit from Monte Rosso, William Hill, Stagecoach, Bruadair and Limitless. Cabernet Sauvignon makes up 82% of the wine, with small additions of Cabernet Franc, Merlot and Malbec. The blend is intended to evoke the classic, food-friendly Napa Cabernets of the 1960s and 1970s.

Read the full review

No. 2: Donelan, Obsidian Estate Syrah 2023

Obsidian Vineyard is a six-acre site in Knights Valley, named for the volcanic rock that runs through its stony soils. After a fire damaged the vineyard, it was replanted in 2017 at denser spacing to help keep yields low. The 2023 release is the first Syrah made from the new vines.

Winemaker David Milner fermented fruit from nine blocks separately, using whole clusters in about a third of the wine and co-fermenting a small amount of Viognier. The finished wine was aged for 21 months in oak. Its layered character is enjoyable now, but it also has the structure to age.

Read the full review

No. 1: Chateau Montelena, The Montelena Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 2023

Chateau Montelena’s top spot comes in a year marking the 50th anniversary of the 1976 Judgment of Paris, the tasting that brought the winery and Napa Valley international attention. The estate remains family-owned, with Bo Barrett overseeing the Calistoga property and winemaker Matt Crafton leading production.

The vineyard sits at the foot of Mount Helena, where varied soils and afternoon sun help shape the wines. The 2023 Cabernet earned a 100-point score, combining ripe Napa fruit with freshness and structure. Its firm, fine-grained tannins and long finish suggest it could become one of the estate’s most long-lived Cabernets in decades.

Read the full review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *