In 1912, Sigmund Freud, a pioneer in psychoanalysis, explored a provocative analogy between wine consumption and erotic pleasure in his essay titled "On the Universal Tendency to Debasement in the Sphere of Love." Freud delved into why the sexual instinct often seems at odds with its capacity for fulfillment. He suggested that when societal barriers—like norms, lack of opportunity, or personal self-denial—impede sexual expression, this instinct thrives in the face of adversity. However, once such barriers are removed, as in the case of marriage, desire can diminish.
Freud intriguingly compared this situation to a drinker’s relationship with wine. He argued that the daily consumption of wine always provides a consistent "toxic satisfaction" without the necessity of variation—unlike sexual relationships that appear to involve a more complex dynamic. He noted the poetic metaphors linking inebriation and erotic pleasure, asserting that scientific evidence supports it. According to Freud, a drinker never finds the need to change their preferred beverage to remain content and noted that seeking alcohol in locations where it’s scarce seems absurd.
Yet, Freud’s analogy raises questions regarding its accuracy. In contemporary society, drinking is often medicalized and laden with restrictions, pushing one to monitor consumption. Whether valuing wine for its health benefits or simply enjoying it socially, a myriad of rules now complicate the enjoyment of drinking. Despite these modern hurdles, observations during social drinking occasions might suggest people still find enjoyment regardless of the surrounding restrictions.
Freud’s primary claim—that a drinker doesn’t tire of their chosen wine—ignores the inherent variability in wine itself. Wines from different regions and vintages vary considerably, and even the same wine can taste different depending on when it’s consumed or how it’s been stored. Thus, while the act of drinking may appear unchanged, the nature of wine guarantees a level of diversity.
In discussing prominent drinkers like the artist Arnold Böcklin, Freud characterized their relationship with alcohol as harmonious, though such an association raises doubts when juxtaposed with the realities of addiction. Ultimately, Freud’s insights, though groundbreaking at the time, oversimplified the complexities of both alcohol consumption and intimate relationships.
Referenced Links: