Pinotage is a fascinating grape variety that has a rich history. Originating from a cross in the 1920s, it faced near extinction but was rediscovered, leading to the first varietal wines produced in the 1950s. Despite its challenges in vinification — it can ferment in unpredictable ways and create reduction issues — winemakers have had success using ripeness and oak to enhance its appeal. However, its true potential lies in producing fresher, lighter reds. Here, six distinct Pinotages have been compared.
Bruce Jack Off The Charts Pinotage 2023, Western Cape, South Africa
13.5% alcohol. This wine presents juicy, sweet fruit flavors, with a palate featuring sour cherry and a slight bitterness. Its lighter style is both expressive and food-friendly, enhanced by a subtle touch of spicy oak. Rated 89/100 (£15.99).
Kleine Zalze Cellar Selection Pinotage 2023, Coastal Region, South Africa
14.5% alcohol. Ripe and fruit-driven, it showcases cherry and raspberry notes along with tannic grip and a hint of balsamic character. The finish balances brightness with slightly bitter elements. Rated 90/100 (£14.64).
Simonsig Redhill Pinotage 2021, Stellenbosch, South Africa
14% alcohol. Known as Simonsig’s first red wine, this Pinotage features ripe black cherry and blackberry aromas, accented by chocolate and spice. Its structure and freshness provide an engaging tasting experience. Rated 92/100 (£26).
Warwick The Black Lady Pinotage 2023, Stellenbosch, South Africa
14% alcohol. Made from bush vines, this wine is dense and flavorful with black cherries and blackcurrants, complemented by tar and spice notes. Its balance of ripeness and elegance hints at its potential. Rated 93/100 (£30).
Rijk’s Touch Pinotage 2020, Tulbagh, South Africa
14.5% alcohol. This rich and expansive Pinotage is marked by sweet fruit flavors and depth, making it enjoyable and approachable, yet still capable of aging. Rated 92/100 (£20).
Olifantsberg Pinotage 2021, Breedekloof, South Africa
12.5% alcohol. Featuring whole berry fermentation, it showcases a bright profile with juicy cherry and raspberry flavors and an elegant finish. Rated 93/100 (£20.99).
These wines represent a diverse expression of Pinotage, showcasing the grape’s potential to evolve and produce remarkable wines.